What is the American standard for acupuncture? – why


After all this he wondered. “If acupuncture already stems from vastly different traditions, and if practitioners end up doing something very different to their patients anyway, then he would prefer one national standard, such as a national qualifying examination. Why are you trying to do it?”

“If I didn’t know anything about Chinese medicine or acupuncture, what they were using… would be a black box of jargon? But I have studied and practiced for 15 years, so I understand. I did,” Fan said. “For me, it was really interesting how they got to those points or how they got to a certain formula,” he said. “None of them were consistent.”

Huang said variations are features, not bugs. To him, acupuncture was like the slime his 8-year-old son used to play with.

“It … sticks to the dirt, it sticks to Lego, and it sticks to everything it touches,” he said. “Chinese medicine has a similar context in terms of culture. It is tied to many cultural practices, regulations and other related medical practices.”

He said trying to create one standardized acupuncture trial in the United States would be like trying to solidify slime, which is pointless and serves no purpose.

Instead, schools should focus on teaching patient safety and the logistics of running a private clinic, he said. Don’t focus too much on the specific types of acupuncture that the Board has determined should be standard.

Tyler Huang prepares to administer acupuncture to a patient.Credit: Nikki Beribault
Tyler Huang prepares to administer acupuncture to a patient. (Courtesy of Nikki Beribault)

This idea is not popular among some acupuncturists. We argue that standards are needed in this field because without standards no one will take them seriously. Licensed acupuncturist Elaine Wolfe Comalou has practiced in Virginia since the 1990s and worked with lawmakers in the state to help pass regulations.

“The regime didn’t have confidence that they knew what we were doing,” she said.

Anyone can be a master of acupuncture, even if they don’t know what they are doing. Although rare, adverse acupuncture outcomes such as bleeding, bruising, and nerve damage can occur.

“I found it helpful to have a test that could be designated as an independent test not offered by the school and could be given some degree of recognition,” Comaro said.

Mina Larson, chief executive of the National Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine Accreditation Board, a national board of acupuncture and moxibustion, said having such standards could also mean that acupuncture is covered by insurance. said.

Larson said having standards and regulations is key to expanding access to this treatment.

He also said the board will review the standards every five years. And they have extensively researched the field to ensure that its regulations apply to different acupuncture traditions and can reflect the diversity of the field. The purpose of the national exam is to ensure that those entering the field understand the basics of physiology and anatomy.

Emily Croatre, a law professor at the University of Kent, UK, is studying how governments regulate alternative medicine. She said there are always trade-offs when applying rules made for Western medicine to other medicines. Staying out means patients can be at risk with expensive treatments, but they are less effective and less reliable. But creating regulations means that organizations will have to decide what acupuncture looks like and who can receive it.

Different countries may come to very different conclusions. For example, in the UK private acupuncturists are not required to register with the State Agency to practice. But in France, just across the English Channel, only health care providers, such as doctors and nurses, can officially give people acupuncture.

Croatre adds that this balancing act applies not only to acupuncture, but also to other Western medical traditions outside the scope of Western biomedicine: Ayurveda, naturopathic medicine, and other types of alternative medicine. rice field.

“When regulating these particular practices, by regulating them according to the standards to which we are accustomed in the West, we should end up justifying only certain forms and rethinking what different traditions should be. There is always the danger of becoming

It’s a delicate balance between setting standards, protecting patient health, and protecting the traditions that made these practices so appealing in the first place.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *