Ranking of celebrities named in the Penguins general manager search

The search for a general manager for the Pittsburgh Penguins is starting to get a few names and seems to be casting a fairly wide net in discussions with candidates.

Frank Serravalli, along with The Athletic’s Rob Rossi and Josh Yohe, delve into a few names, bringing together young up-and-coming analytical minds and some of the common rethink suspects no one wants to know about. It has become a thing. Touch the 10 foot pole.

Let’s take some of the more prominent names that have come up so far and rank them (in my opinion) in terms of how desirable they are as general manager candidates.

1. Eric Tarski carolina hurricanes deputy manager

Tarski has played a key role in building one of the NHL’s best teams, is perhaps one of the sport’s sharpest analytical minds, and has the chance to be a great general manager. He’ll be a general manager one day and he might as well be here. A former Flyers goalie turned ex-Flyers blogger could be a bit of a joke in the general manager’s office.

Carolina has a great front office and hasn’t lost many trades or free agency deals. You can’t give all the credit to the assistant GMs (Don Waddell still has a pretty big say, obviously), but they’ve still done a great job with the best Stanley Cup hockey team in the NHL. was formed. I would love to talk to the people who helped build it.

2. Jason Botterill Seattle Kraken deputy manager

To be honest, when I first saw Botterill’s name mentioned, I ignored it. But Yohe’s article in The Athletic is pretty compelling, and to be honest he probably didn’t get much of a chance in Buffalo. Not only because he was given a brief straitjacket on a team that took him years to get better, but also because he had one of the worst owner groups in the NHL above him. He has a lot of front office experience, has been part of some very good teams, and has held the General Manager chair before, but I would refer to him as any other name going forward. A list that does not look like a type of rehire.

3. Kyle Dubus toronto maple leafs general manager

He said he will either be Toronto’s general manager next season or no one next season. But people say a lot of things at press conferences that aren’t necessarily true. What else is he going to say to a pack of angry dogs after another playoff blowout? “Oh, I can’t wait to get out of here and away from these idiots” probably won’t work.

But I have to admit that I have conflicting thoughts about Dubus.

On the one hand, I think he’s done a great job in terms of building the front office and organizational philosophy in Toronto. They set up a large analytics and sports science department, but Duvas was very active in building a competitive roster. It’s all important.

Where I run into concerns is when I start digging into individual movements. Did they do the right thing? Have they abandoned their plans? Did they focus on the wrong characteristics of players?

Consider here. What if Dubus was telling the truth when he specifically mentioned the “general manager”, whether in Toronto or elsewhere? Also, what if he’s a potential director of hockey operations and someone else takes on the role of general manager?

yes? no?

4. Matthew Darsch tampa bay lightning deputy manager

It’s similar to Tulsky in that they want someone who hasn’t failed another GM job yet, and who comes from a successful, winning organization. Aside from all of the wins, I love how Tampa Bay have built their roster and moved to leverage their core of veterans. The types of players they target in trades, the aggressiveness of their draft picks, how they identify which players to keep, and how quickly they sign deals.

5. Dan McKinnon new jersey devils deputy manager

McKinnon is like an amalgamation of the traits of guys like Tarski and Botterill. The analytics background has a history with the Penguins and played a key role in acquiring a very important player who won the Stanley Cup. He is also part of his office fronting the New Jersey Devils, who built his huge hockey team.

6. John Chaika, ex Arizona Coyotes general manager

Chayka’s name has been mentioned a lot lately, and I’m not sure how I feel about it. I didn’t quite understand him in Arizona or what he was doing there. But it’s also difficult to fully appreciate his performance on The Coyotes, given the turmoil of ownership and the dysfunctional nature of the franchise. How many general managers will actually pull it off? Not many.

7. Jason Karmanos buffalo sabers Associate General Manager

To be honest, I don’t know much about him other than the fact that he helped build a strong analytics department at Buffalo, is another name for the Penguins’ Stanley Cup team, and has ties to the Penguins. yeah. and organization. But what does that mean for the new ownership group? Probably nothing. An interesting name to add to the list, but I’m not sure he’ll be one of our favorites here.

8. Mark Burgevin, ex montreal canadiens general manager

This alone makes me give a big yawn. He built a mediocre Canadiens team for a decade despite having some high-end players in key positions. Carrie Price at her peak? It’s pointless. It’s pretty far down on my list. But still, it’s not as bad as his other two options. We need to get to this point.

9. Stan Bowman, ex chicago blackhawks general manager

There are many reasons why you should say no to this. First of all, we don’t know what he did to get another chance in the NHL after the Kyle Beach ruckus. I’m not saying people shouldn’t give second chances. But to get a second chance, you have to make amends for your mistakes and work hard to fix them. Did that happen here? What steps have you taken other than suspending the NHL and going on hiatus for a year?

Even with those measures, hockey controversy against Bowman persists.

I don’t really care that the Blackhawks have won several Stanley Cups under his watch. Because the majority of the Cup-winning roster was drafted by Mike Smith and Dale Talon. And when Bowman actually had to replace some of those players and really start building a roster, he did a terrible job. There were strong claims that from 2016 until his dismissal last year, he was the bottom five general manager in hockey.

Trade of Artemi Panarin and Brandon Saad.

Used Teubo Teraveinen as compensation for breaking the contract with Brian Bickel.

Seth Jones’ trade and signing was a key part of his final offseason in Chicago, when he legitimately tried to build a playoff team and instead built one of the worst teams in the league. bottom.

His trading record since around 2015 has been more than just losses, it’s been a series of ridiculously bad losses.

It’s a PR nightmare for a general manager who’s been doing shit for the past six years. hard pass.

10. Peter Chiarelli, Ex boston bruins General manager of the Edmonton Oilers

If your organization is hiring Peter Chiarelli for any role, you’re simply not a serious NHL team.

But no.

no way.

Aside from failing to build a playoff team around Conor McDavid and Leon Drysitel in Edmonton, if you look at maybe 10 or 15 of the worst salary-cap-era trades, it’s probably At least three or four of Peter Chiarelli’s trades would fall into that category. list. There are probably more.

Boston has failed to show anything within three years of trading Tyler Seguin. Literally nothing. The whole deal is gone. They got all their assets back. Had disappeared. There is nothing to show against it. The trade tree evaporated to nothing.

Adam Larson’s Taylor Hall.

Players selected by Matthew Balzal and Anthony Beauvilliers in Griffin Reinhart’s 26 games and more.

Jordan Eberle as Ryan Strom.

Let’s take a look at his trading history in Edmonton. Heh, some of his Boston stuff too. From a hockey horror movie.

Do the opposite of what he said in the interview. Maybe that’s the winning formula.

read more

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *